>>58577
Sounds horrible. I much rather liked the Pathfinder approach.
>pick the evil choice
>companion proceeds to slaughter the two wounded allies
>head back to the cave with the remaining survivors and help defend it against an ambush
>maybe guilt tripped?
Alternative:
>pick the good choice
>proceed to help save the two wounded allies
>get back to cave, only to find all the people there slaughtered
Always do what the little evil gnome tells you to. He's right 9/10 times

>>58578
I do. Eggs good