>>4978
I'd say that you try to decide what standard you are going to judge it by. Say, does the Villain's magic destroying Canterlot but being blocked by a piece of debris so Twily can escape bug you? If it's those kind of simple logical nitpicks I think that would be a waste of brain power unless you are writing a fic that deals with that event some how or are really going to nerd out on Magic. I wouldn't let that affect that my rating. I would say that be better to compare and contrast with internal consistency of the show's logic (for example, getting angry for Celestia being stupid from a in real world strategic perspective is one thing, being so stupid that Twilight pointed out how crazy in the universe it is to transfer power in a few days is another). Though even then there is a special problem with the final is that, whenever something happened in the show, I'd wait to see if another episode corroborated it before it could be regarded as canon. Often episode's will have an implication or two that will never go anywhere and only be implied once. (Basically my model is: episode canon, season canon, overall canon or implication that has been made for more than one season). I've been trying to look at overall motifs and dynamics, but with the final, this is the last look. So how should one judge a minor throw away line there?