Tancredo: Open Letter to Pope Francis: Churches have dogmas and missionaries, free nations have constitutions and borders
Description: Open Letter to Pope Francis--Churches Have Dogmas and Missionaries, Free Nations Have Constitutions and Borders
Keywords: ,Big Government, Faith,Pope Francis
Date: 2017-09-18T18:03:33-07:00

SIGN UP FOR THE BREITBART EMAIL NEWSLETTER

# Tancredo: Open Letter to Pope Francis–Churches Have Dogmas and Missionaries, Free Nations Have Constitutions and Borders

Joe Raedle/Getty Images

by Tom Tancredo 18 Sep 2017 0

18 Sep, 2017 18 Sep, 2017

## Your Holiness, recently, I have been criticized for saying that your advocacy of open borders and the U.S. Catholic Church’s aggressive support for amnesty are as much a response to declining church membership as an expression of sincere humanitarian values.

Pope Francis, I am writing to explain that this criticism of persistent Catholic Church meddling in U.S. political affairs is not directed at you personally.

advertisement

In April of 2008, in response to Pope Benedict XVI’s criticism of U.S. immigration policies I said, “This isn’t preaching; it is faith-based marketing.” My statements at that time earned me widespread attacks not only from the New York Times but from the Congressional Hispanic Caucus, the Mexican American Legal Defense Fund, and other partisans of open borders.

Like your predecessor, Pope Benedict XVI, Your Holiness appears to enjoy giving advice on immigration policy to presidents and parliaments.

Here’s a suggestion from a fellow Christian who, like you, strives to be a humble servant of our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ. To the extent that you feel compelled to enter into the political arena and address the subject of immigration policies, why not focus on the enormous differences that exist in those policies around the world?

Certainly you know that the United States of America accepts more legal immigrants than all the other 196 members of the United Nations combined. The USA has also accepted more refugees for permanent resettlement than any other nation of the world. To take a current example, the United States has accepted tens of thousands of Rohingya Muslim and Hindu refugees from Burma (Myanmar), while Burma’s neighboring countries like India, Bangladesh, and Thailand have largely shunned them.

Did I somehow miss a news release from Vatican City praising our generosity towards those persecuted religious refugees? Likewise, did I miss the one announcing the Vatican’s “open door policy” in this matter?

I also respectfully suggest that you and your Cardinals and Bishops need to be more observant of the important distinction between speaking ex cathedra on matters of faith and morals — where among fellow Catholics you presumably have unique expertise and authority — and expressing your personal opinions on purely political matters, where if I may say so, you have no more expertise or authority than artists, journalists, golfers, or the average member of the United States Congress.

I believe most Americans understand and appreciate the historical record that forced the erection of 50 foot walls around the Vatican. They were built to protect and defend. There was a need to restrict entry of those who meant to do harm and also to insure that the integrity of the city-state. Considering the fact that you maintain both the walls and careful scrutiny of those admitted beyond them, you can see why even in the 21st century border security is still an important and necessary part of maintaining a nation state. The fact that the U.S. attempts to accomplish that task while still being the most immigrant-welcoming nation in the world seems to me, should Your Holiness feel compelled to address the issue at all, deserves praise instead of criticism. It is this dichotomy that creates skepticism regarding the motivation of such criticism.

We Americans of the Christian faith have always recognized that churches have a right to propagate the faith and recruit new members; that is part of our First Amendment freedom of religion and freedom of speech. Yet, the corollary to religious freedom is the separation of church and state, so Americans also understand that those necessary and righteous recruitment endeavors must respect and accept a nation’s natural right to protect and defend itself.

P.S. DO YOU WANT MORE ARTICLES
LIKE THIS ONE DELIVERED RIGHT TO YOUR INBOX?
SIGN UP FOR THE DAILY BREITBART NEWSLETTER.

Comment count on this article reflects comments made on Breitbart.com and Facebook. Visit Breitbart's Facebook Page.

BREITBART CONNECT

## MOST POPULAR

- Jerry Brown: CA Is Protecting ‘Hard Working’ Undocumented Immigrants from Washington D.C. ‘Xenophobia’0 comments - 9 hours ago
- Trump Vindicated: Report Says Obama Government Wiretapped Trump Campaign 0 comments - 1 day ago
- Panic Mode: Mitch McConnell’s Senate Leadership Fund Dumps Another Nearly Million Dollars into Alabama 0 comments - 6 hours ago
- Judge Roy Moore: We Removed God from Schools, Shootings and Death Filled the Void 0 comments - 14 hours ago
- Delingpole: Climate Alarmists Finally Admit ‘We Were Wrong About Global Warming’0 comments - 19 hours ago
- Lindsey Graham: Breitbart, Steve Bannon Critical to Passing Federalism-Focused Obamacare Repeal 0 comments - 11 hours ago
- Luther Strange Stands to Profit from Troubled EB-5 Visa Program 0 comments - 7 hours ago
- Dr. Sebastian Gorka to Campaign for Judge Roy Moore Alongside Sarah Palin in Alabama 0 comments - 17 hours ago
- Nolte: MSM Always Knew Trump Camp Was Wiretapped — They Just Lied About It 0 comments - 11 hours ago
- Trump to U.N.: America ‘Among the Greatest Forces for Good in the History of the World’0 comments - 10 hours ago

All About Vonni
Dominic Frisby
Suppressors aren't Silencers

## FROM THE HOMEPAGE

- Luther Strange Stands to Profit from Troubled EB-5 Visa Program
  Comments
- Alabama State Auditor: Luther Strange ‘Self-Serving’ on EB-5 Visas with Ownership in Questionable Program Firm
  Comments
- Panic Mode: Mitch McConnell’s Senate Leadership Fund Dumps Another Nearly Million Dollars into Alabama
  Comments
- Governor Bentley Weighed ‘Trickle-Down Effect’ in Appointing Strange
  Comments
- Socialism or Federalism? Graham-Cassidy Health Care Bill Picks up Steam
  Comments
- Paul Manafort: Justice Department Should ‘Immediately’ Investigate Wiretapping by Obama Administration
  Comments
- WH Sources: Concerns About Crowd Size for Trump-Luther Strange Event; To Be Held at Smaller Venue Than 2016 Rally
  Comments
- Lindsey Graham: Breitbart, Steve Bannon Critical to Passing Federalism-Focused Obamacare Repeal
  Comments
- Virgil: America First or America Last? Trump Abandons Campaign Promise to Sacrifice More Americans to the Afghanistan Meat Grinder
  Comments
- EXCLUSIVE — GRAPHIC: Cartel Incinerates More Bodies near Texas Border
  Comments
- Nolte: MSM Always Knew Trump Camp Was Wiretapped — They Just Lied About It
  Comments
- Establishment Attacks Roy Moore for Condemning Racial Strife Among ‘Black, White, Red, and Yellow,’ As Media Lose Minds
  Comments

SIGN UP FOR THE OFFICIAL
BREITBART EMAIL NEWSLETTER

GET TODAY'S TOP NEWS DELIVERED RIGHT TO YOUR INBOX

I don't want to get today's top news.

x

SIGN UP FOR THE
BREITBART EMAIL NEWSLETTER

x