>>12525
>>12526
Guess who finally sat down and did my ratings? ME!

Some notes:
1):I initially noted with Fall Weather Friends that 6.8 was an arbitrary number, but, I used 6.8 and 6.9 more than once for things that didn't feel quite like a 7 to me but still liked.
2):Feeling Pinkie Keen I was divided between 6.1 and 6.5, and for this graph I decided 6.5. I liked the episode well enough.
3):The Snow Stoppers was a provisional 6.5 rating and it still is. Actually, on rewatch there might be a few episodes I like more or less than some others but that is natural with time and my taste.This graph is accurate enough for right now.
4):Griffon the Brush Off I still enjoyed, but took issue with the lesson, and I rated the lesson in the Episode a 5/10 even if I rated the episode itself at still a 6.5 when it came to personal enjoyment.

> My top episode is of course Winter Wrap-Up at 10, and the lowest is Over a Barrel at 4.6, which would give a mid-range of 7.3, and that sounds about right.
My top is Winter Wrap Up at 9. My lowest is... Griffon the Brush Off for the lesson? IDK, some episodes I enjoyed less than that but I never rated an episode below 6 even if I rated on average more lower than you did.

>10 would be because I think it's probably the high point of the show. So if I had to give it an overall score, I think I'd rank season 1 as a 9.5.
The struggle between personal enjoyment and trying to rate quality. Something I didn't quite figure out even if I leaned into personal enjoyment more as this thread went on. Weirdly I feel quite confident in rating Season 1, a solid 8/10. I think it was great, but not perfect.

> That's my opinion as it stands! And I'm looking forward to seeing how season 2 holds up for me, for Bridge, and for any other anons who wish to join in