Are Girls' Sports Really Safe in Washington State? And Will Voters' Voices Even Matter?
Washington voters have once again been asked to make their voices heard through the initiative process. This time, the issue is the future of girls' sports and whether female athletes should have the right to compete in athletic programs designated for them. Initiative 638 has brought an important question to the forefront: Are girls' sports in Washington being protected, and what happens if the will of the voters is once again challenged, changed, or overturned? The early election results suggest that a majority of Washington voters support Initiative 638. That should mean something. It represents thousands upon thousands of Washingtonians who took the time to sign petitions, consider the issue, and cast their ballots. But there is another question Washington residents have reason to ask: How much confidence should voters have that their decisions will actually stand?
The initiative process: A voice for the people, or a temporary victory? Washington has a long history of voters using initiatives to challenge decisions made by the Legislature. The initiative process was established to give ordinary citizens a direct voice in government and provide a check on elected officials. Yet Washington's history also demonstrates that passing an initiative does not necessarily guarantee that the law will survive. Consider Initiative 695, passed by voters in 1999. It sought to limit vehicle license fees to $30. The Washington Supreme Court ultimately invalidated it. Other voter-approved tax-limitation initiatives have also faced constitutional challenges. There is a difference between a court determining that a measure violates the Constitution and lawmakers subsequently changing a law that voters supported. But from the perspective of a voter, the result can feel remarkably similar: The decision made at the ballot box does not remain intact. Initiative 2081, Washington's parental rights initiative, provides a more recent example. It was passed by the Legislature in 2024 after being submitted through the initiative process. Lawmakers subsequently amended the law in 2025. In 2026, voters were asked whether to restore its original provisions through Initiative 001. This raises a legitimate question about the strength of the initiative process: If citizens go through the effort of gathering signatures and securing voter approval, what protections exist to ensure their decision is respected? What about the girls?